Wednesday, 8 December 2010

The Werewolf by Angela Carter

Read the Angela Carter short story, 'The Werewolf' then answer the following question (in three parts!)

'What is your interpretation/explanation of the story? In what ways is it like/unlike the traditional 'Little Red Riding Hood' fairytale? How does Angela Carter manage to create a dark and sinister atmosphere?'

The Werewolf

Brother's Grimm Story

PowerPoint

12 comments:

  1. Amy Digman : Mr Baxter.

    PARAGRAPH ONE:-

    In the classic fairytale by Brother’s Grimm, the girl, ‘Little Red Riding Hood’ is portrayed as a classic vision of a Victorian England girl:

    “…just as Little Red Riding Hood entered the wood, a wolf appeared. Red Riding Hood did not know what a wicked creature he was, and was not at all afraid of him.”

    This implies to the audience that the girl is innocent and stupid – a common thought of Victorian girls at this time as females were still thought of as inferior males and when they married, they were ‘owned’ by their husbands. When she’s confused by her ‘grandmother’, when it’s really the wolf, her reaction does not change; portraying her further as unintelligent and passive as she doesn’t act upon her confusion.
    In contrast, the girl in ‘The Werewolf’ is shown as headstrong and determined:

    “When she heard that freezing howl of a wolf, she dropped her gifts, seized her knife and turned on the beast.”

    This suggests that the girl was not afraid and was active in the eyes of danger unlike her ‘Brother’s Grimm’ alter-ego. The singular word ‘freezing’ clearly emphasises the extent of terror the wolf’s howl could effect someone however the girl overcomes the fear and translates it into anger as she seizes upon the wolf.


    PARAGRAPH TWO:

    In ‘Little Red Riding Hood’ the weather and atmosphere reflects the young audience:

    “…he said: ‘See, Little Red Riding Hood, how pretty the flowers are about here - …”

    The shows that the area of the wood is peaceful and not dangerous. The word ‘pretty’ similarly relates to the opinion of the girl, as she is innocent but dim-witted – much like pretty girls are perceived. The weather may be bright and the scenery appealing to be appropriate for the audience of young children.
    To compare, ‘The Werewolf’ weather and scenery is bitter and cruel:

    “Cold; tempest;...”

    These two individual words show the area and life to be hard and dangerous for all who survive there. There is pathetic fallacy is this phrase and the choice of words represent the wild and unpredictable life they lead with suffer and despair as ‘tempest’ defined means: wild and brutal storm.
    The two weather descriptions reflect the different stories well, showing one as happy and uplifting whereas the other is developed as very dark and puzzling.

    ReplyDelete
  2. One of the key differences between “the werewolf” and the traditional “red ridding hood” is the girl in the stories: on the one hand you have a: sweet; lovable; kind; innocent; honest girl wear as in the modern telling of the traditional story “the werewolf” the girl is depicted as a brutal ; manipulative and in some cases brave.
    Firstly you notice the clothing worn by the characters they are completely different for example red ridding hood wears red, red symbolising: love; happiness; excitement this clothing depicts the girl wearing them as a girly girl and that she is innocent and furthermore typically “blonde”. Wear as the clothing worn by the modern telling she is depicted as a street wise girl who only wore functional cloths such as the bland as she wears a “shabby sheep skin cloak” “to keep the cold out” this shows that she does not have a lot of money furthermore her family do not spend money on her this could show that she had a troubled upbringing and that could be one of the reasons the is portrayed in this version of the story as a cold hearted killer.

    Another key aspect of the stories is the setting; this is also one of the main differences in the two interpretations of the classic red ridding hood. Firstly in the classic traditional telling the setting; it is set in a pleasant day the birds are singing the sun is shining and the wood is depicted as “pretty”. This furthermore instating how the woods are a “safe” place. One the other hand the woods is portrayed as a cold desolate and the walk to her grandmothers was shown as a “five mile through heavy snow” rather than in the traditional version it is shown “as a few leagues” witch is no more than a mile these are two completely contrasting interpretations as one is a small walk in the sunny forest and the other is a hard five mile gruelling trek. Another difference to the way in witch they have been written is the purpose of the being written for example the traditional story was written to educate “to listen to your elders” were as the newer version was written to show that in some circumstances people can do different things also to show that girls have another side to them.

    Raf

    ReplyDelete
  3. “The Werewolf” and “Little Rid Riding hood” both have the fundamental elements of a fairytale. They are both focused around a young girl and how the different depiction of her personality in the two stories, both featuring in two different time-frames, ultimately alters her fate. In the two stories the setting’s are very different, this powerfully alters the meaning and overall mood of the stories.

    The setting of “The werewolf” is much darker and mysterious; this almost taints the story, ultimately making it much less of a traditional fairy tale - in which younger children are the main audience:

    “Cold; tempest; wild beasts in the forest.”

    This quote boldly suggests the sheer negativity that is trying to be inflicted upon the reader, the use of semi colons shows how the author actually has to list the fierce and dark motives of the forest. However it is done is such a way that the use of semi colons adds tension to the story, making every word count towards the powerful description. The use of “tempest” also focuses the reader on how horror stricken the scene is. The use of such a powerful word shows how vividly the author is trying to engage the audience and make us feel like we are actually playing a part in the story. Right from the first line of the story we are bombarded with harsh and powerful description of the scene, this is maintained throughout the story constantly keeping us aware of the situation.

    Comparatively in the original “Little Red Riding Hood” we are made to experience the complete opposite, within the first few lines we are met with serenity, love and caring. The setting is much more of typical fairy tale in which “they all live happily ever after” but still contains a valuable lesson that is intended for its purpose audience which is younger children:

    “See, Little Red Riding Hood, how pretty the flowers are about here”

    This quote demonstrates the simplicity of the description very well, as the flowers are merely described as “pretty” to me this suggests that the flowers we nothing special and that they were only pretty, however for the target audience “pretty” is all that is needed to depict a beautiful scene. Over all though we see the quote adding a sense of happiness to the story as it is showing expressing the beauty of the nature that surrounds the story. This is much more positive and child friendly compared to the werewolf in which we are met with harsh negativity.



    Another vital difference in the two stories is the girl. In the original tale we see how the girl is very caring, sweet and innocent. She is portrayed to be a very contemporary girl, of who is not very intelligent and struggles to notice a transvestite wolf:

    “There was a dear little girl”

    The very simply shows the audience how the girl is very sweet, but the way the language appears to be very patronising “dear little” seems to immediately suggest that she is not very clever and that she has many lessons to learn - however the purpose of the story is to educate the girl and the audience with the moral of the story.


    In comparison we see that the girl is much more brave and intelligent in the modern version, she also has a much higher level of street wise and fulfils the role of a much more contemporary girl of recent times, the girl is said to be wearing:

    “a shabby sheep skin cloak”

    This quote shows that girl is much more prepared and understanding about the dangers that lurk in the forest, her mother’s assumptions that she “knows how to use” her father’s hunting knife reinforces this and proves that she is much more utilitarian than the week and feeble girl from Little Red Riding Hood. Overall this just shows how stereotypical this girl is of the Victorian era, upon which women would not serve many purposes out of the house.

    Adam

    ReplyDelete
  4. There are extreme contrasts in the portrayal of the girl in the Brothers Grimms’ Little Red Riding Hood and Angelea Carter’s The Werewolf to analyse these differences we must appreciate the authors intentions and contextual implication:

    ‘Harsh, brief, poor lives.’

    To comprehend the character of the girl in The Werewolf we must understand the world in which she grew up in and how this influences her actions. ‘Harsh’ this adjective represents how the girl’s actions are a product of the environment in which she developed somewhat justifying her malevolent behaviour. The word ‘brief’ displays how the girl’s actions stem from desperation to make the most of her situation as her life is only rapid. ‘Poor’ this gives us insight into the poverty she constantly experiences and how this alters her motive for gaining her Grandmothers property; displaying to us these negative characteristics eg. manipulative, deceitful are the results of her perpetual struggle against the impoverished lifestyle she lives.

    However in the original story as first written by the Brothers Grimm we receive an entirely different interpretation of the girl of whom the story gravitates around:

    ‘Once upon a time there was a dear girl who was loved by everyone who looked at her’

    The phrase ‘girl who was loved by everyone who looked at her’ gives us insight into how in this period of time male supremacy was thoroughly accepted and the females were simply expected to simply ‘looked at’ and not possess any intellectual value. This differs greatly from the girl in Angelea Carter’s The Werewolf as the girls success is entirely dependent on her own ability and competence and not her aesthetic beauty.

    Chloe w

    ReplyDelete
  5. In the classic children’s fairytale, written by Brothers Grimm, Little Red Riding Hood, the main character, Red Riding Hood, seems to be portrayed as vulnerable young girl while entering the woods:
    ‘…just as Little Red Riding Hood entered the wood, a wolf met her. Red Riding Hood did not know what a wicked creature he was, and was not at all afraid of him.’
    This quotation shows Red Riding Hood to be naïve towards the dangers of the woods. This suggests the character Red Riding Hood was defenceless against any dangers that were to become apparent in the woods. This also represents the stereotype of women back in Victorian times, back when Little Red Riding Hood was told and first written, in that the women were incapable of defending themselves and were unaware of any dangers and needed to be protected. The word “wicked” creates an evil character within the reader’s mind, but without making the story too frightening, as it is directed at a young audience. The inclusion of saying Red Riding Hood was not afraid shows the reader that she was ignorant to what the wolf’s intentions were. This also portrays the little girl as very innocent, but also stupid, as she doesn’t know of anything threat she may encounter during her life, like the character of the wolf.

    However, in Angela Carter’s version of Little Red Riding Hood, The Werewolf, the girl is almost completely opposite to the one in Brothers Grimm:
    “Here, take your father’s hunting knife, you know how to use it.”
    This sentence, spoken from the mother to the daughter, shows the audience that the young girl is aware of dangers and prepared to protect herself against them. This also would suggest the girl was very intelligent, as a girl of her age typically wouldn’t know how to use a knife, and the girl is furthermore portrayed as courageous, as many people, even with more understanding than a young girl, would be afraid in dangerous situations where a knife would need using, and the girls knowledge and experience with her father’s hunting knife is implied by the quote. The inclusion of “your father’s hunting knife” would still imply women were seen as inferior to men, similarly as in the Brother’s Grimm version, as it would show women were still seen as needing protection from men. However, this may suggest women couldn’t protect themselves, but this is disproved by the quote, suggesting women accepted their inferiority but learnt how to protect themselves. This was the motive of the story, as it shows women capable of anything men are, which is obviously what Carter, as a feminist, was trying to expose, which she achieved by the use of miserable weather, because it creates a dark and more sinister atmosphere, which reflected on the characters attitudes in both stories, as the weather in Little Red Riding Hood was bright and happy, as was the girl.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Angela Carter derives ‘The Werewolf’ from the original children’s story of ‘Little Red Riding Hood’. Her version contrasts the girl and the attitude towards her in modern times, which completely differs from the traditional outlook on Victorian girls from the initial story.
    “When she heard that freezing howl of a wolf, she dropped her gifts, seized her knife and turned on the beast.”
    This suggests that she has courage and bravery facing the unknown in the forest, which emphasises the break away from the conventional Victorian girl who would ‘died of fright at the sight of it’. Also the words “freezing howl” implies fear and an uneasy atmosphere, which the girl manages to overcome. This demonstrates that she is very independent and not easily scared, creating a large distinction between both girls in each story. This is portrayed again, ‘seized her knife and turned on the beast’ suggests that she isn’t a passive character and demonstrates that she is competent enough to defend herself, unlike ‘Red Riding Hood’ who needs a dominant male to save her from frightening encounters. This confirms a more feminist point of view from Angela Carter as it illustrates women can be strong, powerful and independent through their actions, which is verified by the female character in ‘The Werewolf’.


    Brothers Grimm portrays a traditional approach, which closely bases the story with the original and does not improvise from it. ‘Little Red Riding Hood’ contrasts with Carter’s impression because she is written to be the conventional Victorian girl and doesn’t press to be individual.
    “Ah, how frightened I have been! How dark it was inside the wolf.”
    This shows how passive ‘Riding Hood’ is and how the storyteller wants her to appear useless. At this point ‘the huntsman’ has rescued her, demonstrating the active role men played in the Victorian society. This follows along with many stories as the male figure emerges to be dominant and proceeds to be the saviour for innocent, distressed female. “Ah, how frightened I have been!” suggests she has been waiting for some kind rescuer to fulfil the male role in present and future tenses. This proves her submissive position in the story that completely differs from Carter’s modern approach as she writes a more dynamic, successful character, which establishes to be self-sufficient. Both characters have ‘prospered’ in certain ways but by which Carter’s perception had been more devious and deceptive to profit on an advantage. Demonstrating the distinguishing assets conflicting between them.

    Emily Hill

    ReplyDelete
  7. 1:
    ‘The Werewolf’ and ‘Little Red Riding Hood’ are both adaptations of a classic fairytale, but have different themes that make them suited for different audiences. The settings are both the typical wood atmosphere, though Little Red Riding Hood’s is more innocent and childlike:

    ‘She saw the sunbeams dancing here and there through the trees, and pretty flowers growing everywhere.’

    Firstly, we can tell this sentence is to appeal to younger audiences that the story was intended for, by using uncomplicated vocabulary and appealing nouns to a young mind. For example, the word ‘sun’ is familiar with children and is symbolic for happiness and brightness, which gives the story a more carefree atmosphere. This could’ve been due to Carter’s intentions to give the story a more fairytale-like approach as opposed to ‘The Werewolf’:

    ‘It is a Northern country; the have cold weather, the have cold hearts.’

    Carter seems to write this opening sentence slow-paced, to build up a tense atmosphere that immediately shows that the story will be more appealing to older audiences.

    2:
    Another element that makes the two stories different is the way Little Red Riding Hood is portrayed:

    ‘As long as I live, I will never leave the path by myself to run into the wood, when my mother has forbidden me to do so.’

    This illustrates that Little Red Riding Hood is a thoughtful and wise young girl, made so by her experience with her grandmother and the wolf. It also gives a sense of innocence, and could be seen as a typical young Victorian girl as she is perceived as naive and obedient, doing as she is told and accepting consequences for her actions. The word ‘Never’ clearly shows this.

    ‘She knew the forest too well to fear it but she must always be on her guard.’

    This is a different take on a classic character, making the child more aware and experienced than in the original Grimm fairytale. The phrase ‘On her guard’ gives Little Red a tougher attitude, which is very unlike the typical idea of a girl at this time.

    Hannah R

    ReplyDelete
  8. The settings in ‘The werewolf’ and ‘Little Red Riding Hood’ are very different.
    In ‘Little Red Riding Hood’ the story is set in a forest that is a very light and friendly forest.
    ‘She saw the sunbeams dancing…and pretty flowers growing’
    This suggests that the story is very simple and fun instead of being harsh and sinister. This setting also implies that the audience for this film are young and that they shouldn’t be scared. The setting also says that the story has a clear path to walk through and that it is less than a mile to walk to grandma’s house. This suggests that the story is meant to be jolly and cheerful.

    In contrast, the setting in ‘The Werewolf’ is very different to the setting in ‘Little Red Riding Hood’. Although, in ‘The Werewolf’, it is still set in a forest, the terrain is much different.
    ‘Soon it came on to snow so thickly that the path and any footsteps, track or spoor that might have been upon it were obscured’.
    This suggests that it is still based on the original story but has been adapted to show a different and more realistic perspective. This suggests that the desired audience of this short story would be more sophisticated than the other story. Carter also writes two paragraphs about the level of superstition that the people believe. This key information about the setting helps you read between the lines of the story and work out the hidden story line. This also suggests that the intended audience would be a more intelligent one because people who just read the words would not understand the full content of the story.

    Kilian Stenning

    ReplyDelete
  9. In Angela Carter’s ‘The Werewolf’ the young girl is described as independent.

    ‘Here, take your fathers hunting knife; you know how to use it.’

    This quote implies that the girl is skilled with the weapon and has an understanding on how to use the knife, presenting her as an autonomous, vicious being. The word ‘knife’ is interpreted as a malevolent weapon; it’s used to hurt and threaten others. Relating it to the girl and implying that she has an understanding of the blade, shows that she is well above her age in her mental ability to accept iniquity. Her nonchalance toward the object in this story represents her as a knowledgeable and sadistic girl; this can be explained as Carter is a feminist writer. Her writing is used to influence men and women alike, to realise the capability of the modern women. She writes to demonstrate women’s abilities and the injustice of men dominance. This explains why we see the young girl as a wicked and cunning individual, acting as she and others see men.

    In comparison, Brothers Grimm’s interpretation of ‘Little Red Riding Hood’ shows the girl as a vulnerable, pathetic personality.

    ‘See, Little Red Riding Hood, how pretty the flowers are about here – why do you not look around? ..’

    By letting the wolf sway her into disobeying her mum, she is presented as an obtuse young girl with no sense to ignore a talking wolf. Whereas, in Carters ‘The Werewolf’ the girl shows no hesitation in the ‘so called’ wolf, she slices his hand with no thoughts to her morals. Her stupidity in this situation leads to her almost killing herself and her Grandmother. ‘The werewolf’ being written by a feminist shows us a completely different view of the traditional story that was written in Victorian England. Being written in Victorian times allows us to understand why the young girl is portrayed as ignorant and dependent on the man as that was the expectations of that time.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Part 1 By Phoebe Gee
    Here we can see two very similar stories based on the same story line, however they both have very different outcomes and very different messages along with them. The setting for each story immediately creates an atmosphere, both of which are extremely different. In ‘Little Red Riding Hood’ we see a very happy and jolly scene, with flowers surrounding the wood making everything very pretty and girly like, which is very traditional in a fairy story. "How pretty the flowers are about here" is said by the wolf, to persuade the little Girl. This implies that the flowers must be that beautiful, that they will hopefully lose the girl in the wood. Also, flowers are usually associated with happiness and spring time, giving the story a very warm and relaxing atmosphere, making it a much more suitable story to tell children.

    Much unlike ‘Little red riding hood’, ‘the werewolf’ seems to be aimed at a much older audience. Not only is the description much scarier, but the storyline is also more complicated and harder to understand making it appeal to an older audience. The place and setting is described as "Cold; Tempest; wild beasts in the forest. It is a hard life." The weather and surroundings create a dark and scary atmosphere contributing to the fact this story would scare younger children rather than appeal to them. The fact that there is a lot of punctuation in such a short sentence, mostly being semi-colons, also makes things scarier, creating many pauses as it is read allowing the reader to think about each description as it is said, it also emphasises the sentence in general, making you read it slower, which makes it stand out clearer. It isn’t even just a short pause using a comma, its a much longer pause giving you a much longer time to really think, in depth, about the horrific setting that is described.

    The girl in each story is also significantly different. In "Little red riding hood" she is portrayed as innocent and usually very obedient to her mother’s orders. She is a typical young girl, who could also be portrayed as slightly dumb. She allows herself to wonder in to the wood, looking for flowers, as ordered to by the wolf, which surprisingly she wasn’t afraid of. She was told by her mother to "Stay on the path" however, on this occasion she stupidly listened to the wolf. Then when she turns up at her grandma's house, and the wolf has dressed up as the grandma, Little Red Riding Hood doesn’t even realise resulting in her then getting eaten too. The postman then acts as the typical hero, which is usually needed in every traditional fairy story, being a man, he takes this place nicely then coming to save Little Red Riding Hood, as well as her grandmother. Finally, everything turns out happy, and takes the shape of a 'happily ever after' ending. -This message being always listens to your mother which is very convenient as the children listening to this story, are much more likely to take this message on board.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Phoebe Gee (Part 11) says

    The Girl in "The Werewolf" is very different. She is independent, brave and quite boisterous. On her journey to her grandmother’s house, she even takes her dads hunting knife, which very unusually, she already knows how to use it implying that she may have to have used it before. No other average little girl would even be trusted with a knife, let alone be expected to use it in an emergency for protection showing just how little this family have. The last line of the story "She Prospered." almost sets the scene for the whole story, making the girl seem very selfish, as it seems as though she killed her grandma, just so she could have her house, the kind of house she had always dreamed of. Then, very selfishly, she tries to cover up her story. I think this story is cleverly written as it requires a lot of thinking in order to understand the meaning, however once you have understood the overall story line which seems almost hidden, it is quite a strong and powerful enabling it to really get the message of the story across.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Alessio says

    Both of the stories present the same characters and setting but the intentions and outcomes are different. Angela Carter portrays the story in a dark way; this is shown by the way the weather and how everything is portrayed much more harshly in Angela’s interpretation, whereas in the Brothers Grimm interpretation, the weather and atmosphere is much more positive and simple for the audience to understand. “He said: ‘See, Little Red Riding Hood, how pretty the flowers are about here.”
    This line clearly shows that the wood and the area surrounding it are completely safe and peaceful. The word “pretty” was used by the wolf to distract little red riding hood’s attention, showing that the character is easily distracted by the surrounding environment. However the Angela Carter interpretation the surroundings and environment is much more harsh. “Five miles’ trudge through the forest; do not leave the path because of the bears, the wild boar, the starving wolves.” This line highlights the dangers of the forest, and how there are animals waiting to prey on the people who live there. The word “wild” shows that the animals inhabiting the area are incredibly violent and have no pity one people that pass by them. The two descriptions of the woods reflect the different stories well, showing one as happy and pretty whereas the other is portrayed as very dark and sinister.

    ReplyDelete

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.