Wednesday, 16 March 2011

Is George right to shoot Lennie?


Post your opinion as a comment on this post. Remember to try to explain your answer in as much detail as you can.

9 comments:

  1. Matthew Raven and Jack Sheppard17 March 2011 at 12:17

    In our opinion george was right to kill lennie as it saves him from suffering at the hands of curley. Also lennie was becoming a danger to himself and other people as he was accidentally killing people.On the other hand though George will have to live with his guilt for the rest of his life.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Ruth and Charlotte17 March 2011 at 12:19

    We think that George was right to shoot Lennie because it would have been less painful for Lennie as the alternative was to be caught and tortured by the rest of the ranch workers. However, George may also have seen Lennie as a buerden during their journey and therefore might have shot him out of selfishness. Overall, George saved Lennie from a painful death and therefore acted sleflessly for his friend who he had cared for for many years.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think George was right to shoot Lennie because he was protecting him from what would happen if the other people found him. George did the hardest thing possible to do to a person you love.
    'The hand shook violently'
    this implies he didn't really want to do it as his hand was shaking as his fingers were going over the trigger. The word 'violently' shows his hand wasnt just shaking it was shaking violently.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Sarah and Chloe17 March 2011 at 12:21

    George was right to shoot Lennie. Lennie could of been tortured and jailed for killing Curley's wife, therefore shooting Lennie saved him pain. Although George will feel guilty for the rest of his life, shooting Lennie was the right thing to do. It was a selfless act and the consequences are positive and negative.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think that George was right to kill Lennie as he was become a danger to himself and others around him. It also stops Curley or Carlson making him suffer when they kill him. It does however mean that George will have to live with the guilt for the rest of his life.

    ReplyDelete
  6. George is right. George wanted to be able to kill Lennie because he knew that everyone else was angry and they were out to kill him. He wanted to kill Lennit because he knew that if someone else had killed him they would have tortured him, and if George killed him it would have been quick and easy. It was a selfish act but it would have been more selfish if he would have let the others kill him. He would grieve for a long time if he would have let that happen.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Ella Bushnell & Alice Walker17 March 2011 at 12:23

    We think that George was right to kill Lennie because George had been 'assigned' to Lennie's carer in a way for a long time and therefore he had some say in the choices for Lennie's death. Also, if George hadn't shot Lennie, the others would have and he would have suffered more. Therefore, George was protecting Lennie in a way. However, George sometimes saw Lennie as a burden when they were travelling. George replaced that small burden with the guilt of killing his friend, which is a negative consequence.

    ReplyDelete
  8. It is very debatable as to whether or not George was right to shoot Lennie, many would think it was a noble thing to do. Saving his friend the pain of a beating at the hands of an angry mob, but many would also say it was a cowardly act. Shooting his friend without him knowing,

    ReplyDelete
  9. George probably killed Lennie in order to keep him innocent and believing the American Dream, so that's why he didn't tell Lennie that he was going to shoot him.
    In addition, this act sentenced him to a life of the 'loneliest men in the world', so it wasn't selfish.

    ReplyDelete

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.